The Urgency of Fulfilling Terms and Conditions in Islamic Business Partnership Contracts
One of foundations of Islamic finance is business contracts like mudharabah and musharakah. These contracts depend on openness, trust and rigorous adherence to terms and conditions that have been agreed upon by both parties. According to Islamic jurisprudence upholding these terms is mandatory and has a direct impact on the legitimacy of the contract as well as the equitable allocation of rights and obligations. In reality disagreements and unfairness in business relationships are frequently caused by breaches of the terms that were agreed upon. Therefore adhering to terms and conditions in Islamic business partnerships is a religious obligation and the cornerstone of justice not just good business practice.
Islamic Foundation for Terms and Conditions Fulfillment
Commitment to agreements is emphasized in Islam. It was said by the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ in his hadith:
المسلمون على شروطهم
Muslims are binded by their terms and conditions (Narrated by Abu Daud:3594).
The shariah and ethical foundation extracted from this hadith is that any term that does not conflict with Islamic teachings must be adhered to. Ignoring such clauses may render the contract void or subject you to liability for any harm that results.
Also read:Does Mudharabah fit All Business Funding?
Repercussions for Breaking Agreements in Business Partnership in Islamic Law
There are two main consecuences for breaking any agreement in a partnership based on the end result:
1. Duty to make up for losses: Either the investor (shahib al-maal) or the business owner (mudharib) is liable for any damages brought on by their violation. According to sharia a mudharib who commits negligence (taqshir) or misconduct (ta‘addi) or breach of terms (mukhalafat Asy-syurut) is responsible for the harm caused.
2. Proportionately profits are still distributed: Even in the event of a breach the ventures profit is still allocated according to the previously agreed ratio. However any harm brought on by the violation will requires monetary compensation.
Also read:Types of Mudharabah in Islamic Finance
Examples of term violations in Islamic business partnerships
Project or PO Funding Being Diverted to Unrelated Initiatives
It is a violation of the terms if the investor expressly allots funds for a particular project or purchase order (PO) and then uses those funds for another project even one that is similar. This frequently happens in financing that is based on construction or PO. When such clauses are broken the party at fault must make up for any losses or risks brought about by the diversion because they constitute a restriction on the use of capital (shart taqyid).
Violation of Geographic Constraints
Contracts can occasionally restrict company operations to a particular region (e. g. A. within a single nation or city). It is a clear violation if the business owner increases operations beyond the predetermined boundaries without permission. The breach damages trust and may void rights to profit or end the agreement even if the prolonged operations are legal.
Utilizing Investment Money for Private Purposes
Investment funds must only be utilized for the agreed-upon business. It is a betrayal of trust to use money for personal expenses such as private purchases or debts unrelated to business. Islam demands that the person who misused the money return it and perhaps forfeit any profits made from it
Lack of Mudharib’s Supervision and Risk Management
The business must be responsibly managed by the mudharib. It is considered taqshir (negligence) if they disregard oversight forego routine reporting or disregard risk mitigation (such as insurance or feasibility studies). The mudharib cannot assert protection under losses borne by the investor if this negligence causes loss because they broke the terms of fiduciary responsibility.
Also read:Profits Distribution in Mudharabah & Musyarakah: Permissible with High Cash Reserves?
Violation of Non-Competitive Agreement (NCA)
One of the common terms used in business partnership contract is non-competitive agreement (NCA). This is a breach of mutual trust and unethical competition if they violate it by starting a similar business that competes with the current business. This can negatively impact the performance and sustainability of the current business.
Violation of Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA)
NDAs are frequently included to safeguard confidential company data including pricing models, client lists and strategies. Unauthorized disclosure of this information to third parties is against the terms of the contract and moral principles. This is regarded as khiyanah (betrayal) in Islam particularly if it results in harm for the business.
Also read:Musyarakah Contracts and Capital Guarantee: What You Need to Know
Financial Report Falsification
It is forbidden to purposefully falsify financial records in order to hide losses, understate income or defend financial abuse. Ghish (fraud) which are strictly forbidden apply to this. Such behavior erodes trust and supports the impacted partys demand for reimbursement or the termination of the contract.
Postponing Profit Distribution without a Good Reason
Unjustified withholding (mumatalah) occurs when profits are due and payable and distribution is delayed without a valid reason such as short-term liquidity constraints. If done willfully or negligently this transgresses Islamic legal and ethical requirements.
More Examples
Forming a new company with investment fund, giving managerial control to unapproved parties or making significant decisions without partner approval are examples of additional violations. Fundamental principles of Islamic contracts such as mutual consultation (shura) and consent (taradhi) are all violated by these.
Also read:Profit Sharing in Mudarabah and Musyarakah, Is It Allowed?
In Conclusion
Maintaining Shariah compliance equity and trust in Islamic business partnerships requires that agreed terms and conditions be met. Violations may result in material and moral liability in addition to endangering the validity of the contract. In addition to being required by law all parties must comprehend concur upon and continuously abide by all terms as a representation of Islamic principles in business dealings.
Let’s Visit, Zeed and join for halal investment with Zeed.
References
- AAOIFI. (2017). Shariah Standards. Bahrain: Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Financial Institutions.
- Abu Dawud. (n.d.). Sunan Abi Dawud, Hadith No. 3594.
- Islamway. (2004). Liability of the Mudharib in Cases of Misconduct or Negligence. Retrieved from https://ar.islamway.net/fatwa/41783
- Al-Iftaa Jordan. (2020). Fatwa No. 3911. Retrieved from https://www.aliftaa.jo/fatwa/3911/
- Shamela. (n.d.). Fath al-Bari, Book of Transactions. Retrieved from https://shamela.ws/book/1425/127
- Shamela. (n.d.). Al-Mughni by Ibn Qudamah. Retrieved from https://shamela.ws/book/968/1197
